Accuracy of torque controllers on healing abutments in implant dentistry—an in vitro study

Purpose: To evaluate the accuracy of three torque-control devices used on healing abutments in implant prosthodontics. Materials and Methods: In this in vitro experiment, three torque controllers, Ankylos friction-based, Straumann spring-based, and Anthogyr pre-calibrated torque control devices were used to tighten the healing abutments of Ankylos and Straumann dental implants to a pre-determined value of 15 Ncm. A digital torque meter (DT), Cedar DID-4A, was used to assess removal torque as a surrogate for the accuracy of the torque controllers to apply a tightening force of 15 Ncm on healing abutments. One-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was used to identify differences between each torque controller and the digital torquemeter, a p < 0.05 was considered significant. Results: The torque required to remove the healing abutments was 16.05 ± 0.66 Ncm for the Ankylos ratchet, 12.61 ± 0.90 Ncm for the Straumann ratchet, and 14.37 ± 1.08 Ncm for the Anthogyr torque-control device. Significant statistical differences were observed between Ankylos and the control digital torquemeter (p = 1.84E⁻⁸; F = 50.3); Anthogyr and control digital torquemeter (p = 0.01; F = 6.79); and Straumann and control digital torquemeter (p = 0.01; F = 141.15). Conclusion: Friction-based (Ankylos), spring-based (Straumann), and pre-calibrated (Anthogyr) torque control devices present over-torque and under-torque values when used over healing abutments of Ankylos and Straumann implant systems.