An assessment of the total Lagrangian material point method: Comparison to conventional MPM, higher order basis, and treatment of near-incompressibility

The total Lagrangian material point method (TLMPM) is a recent modification to the conventional material point method (MPM). It poses the weak form in the undeformed configuration, and has shown great potential in solid mechanics applications because it seamlessly eliminates the so-called cell-crossing instability and overcomes numerical fracture. Despite its promise, it has not been widely adopted by the MPM community yet, and only a handful of research groups have employed it. At the same time, due to TLMPM's recent appearance, there are open research questions, such as the subject of near-incompressibility that has not been thoroughly studied within its context. In this paper we attempt to strengthen TLMPM's position in the field by providing an independent assessment of the method in a set of benchmark problems. Furthermore, we evaluate the need of using higher order spline shape functions, which have been shown to be crucial for the success of the conventional MPM. Finally, we present a simple projection technique for addressing solid mechanics problems that fall within the near-incompressible regime. The numerical results show that TLMPM is indeed a strong alternative to conventional MPM, whereas our near-incompressibility approach produces solutions that are free of volumetric locking and pressure oscillations, while introducing very minor modifications to existing codes.