Exploring shame in engineering education

Individual experiences of inclusion or exclusion are increasingly recognized for their relevance in relation to attracting and retaining diverse students in engineering programs. Referring to this emerging body of work, this article explores the emotion of shame as a psychological and sociological construct that might underpin student experiences of inclusion, exclusion, or belonging in engineering majors. To begin unpacking this underexplored concept in the engineering context, we draw on literature from psychology that conceptualizes shame as a construct of emotion with dynamics that greatly affect an individual's perceived experience. We also examine sociological perspectives on shame that attend to how this emotion exists in an intersubjective reality between an individual and his or her social context. Finally, we review the sparse literature in engineering education that explicitly mentions shame and examine a larger body of literature that suggests how engineering student experiences that can be understood as phenomena related shame. This survey of the literature points to the importance of considering shame in engineering education and, in its synthesis, provides the theoretical basis for future empirical studies.