Interactive effects of porewater nutrient enrichment, bioturbation and sediment characteristics on benthic assemblages in sandy sediments

Effective management of eutrophic ecosystems requires an understanding of how nutrient input affects the structure and function of benthic communities. The effects of nutrients in soft sediment habitats can be influenced by a variety of factors including sediment characteristics, hydrodynamic exposure, and the presence of bioturbating macroinvertebrates. We used a large scale exclusion experiment (400 m² areas, n = 6) to test if bioturbating lugworms, Arenicola marina mediate the effects of nutrient enrichment. We incorporated small plots (30 × 30 cm) dosed with household garden fertilizer within the lugworm exclusion and corresponding control areas and predicted that the effects of nutrient enrichment would be greater in the absence of lugworms. We found that the increases in nutrient concentrations were higher in the absence of lugworms, but only in the less permeable sediment in the low intertidal zone compared to the more permeable sediment in the high intertidal. Contrary to expectations, the accumulation of nutrients in the plots did not affect the organic matter and chlorophyll levels in the sediment. Interestingly, there were overall negative effects of nutrient additions on some of the most abundant molluscs, Hydrobia ulvae, Retusa obtusa and juvenile Cerastoderma edule. Possible explanations for these adverse effects such as the changes in the sediment chemistry or the physical presence of the fertilizer in the sediment caused by the nutrient additions are discussed. We conclude that the effects of nutrient enrichment in soft sediment habitats on benthic assemblages are determined by the interplay between the presence of bioturbating macroinvertebrates, tidal height and sediment characteristics.